The Hon. Miss Justice Ingrid Mangatal

Custody - Care and control of 5 year old girl - Welfare of the child - Paramountcy principle - Relocation application - Practice and procedure - Application to strike out portions of affidavits made at trial - Undesirability of such procedure at trial - Maintenance - Responsibility of both parents

Civil practice and procedure – Security for costs application – Section 388 of Companies Act – Court’s power to stipulate time – Part 24 of the CPR – Delay in making application – Relevance of relative impecuniosity of claimant company to more prosperous defendant – Avoidance of both oppressive use of security for costs application and of state of impecuniosity – Whether claim only or whole of proceedings stayed – Appropriate order for costs on successful application for security for costs

Application to strike out portions of witness statement - Whether inconsistent with statements of case - Scope of declaratory relief.

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA 
IN COMMON LAW
SUIT NO. C.L. 2002/W-062
BETWEEN LINCOLN WATSON CLAIMANT
AND PAULA NELSON lStD EFENDANT
C:
AND FITZ MULLINGS 2nd DEFENDANT
Heard - 2nd and 9" December, 2003
Mr. Jeffrey Mordecai for the Claimant
Miss Camille Wignall and Miss Minto instructed by Nunes
Scholefield, DeLeon & Co. for the 1" Defendant
MANGATAL J (Ag.)
C. 1. Lincoln Watson claims that on the 1 1" of December, 1997 Fitz
Mullings so negligently drove Paula Nelson's motor vehicle at the

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA
IN COMMON LAW
SUIT NO. C.L. 2002lW-062
BET WEEN LINCOLN WATSON CLAIMANT
AND PAULA NELSON 1 DEFENDANT
AND FITZ MLJLLINGS 2nd DEFENDANT
Heard - 2nd and 9" December, 2003
Mr. Jeffrey Mordecai for the Claimant
Miss Camille Wignall and Miss Minto instructed by Nunes
Scholefield, DeLeon & Co. for the lst Defendant
MANGATAL J (Ag.)
1. Lincoln Watson claims that on the 1 1" of December, 1997 Fitz
Mullings so negligently drove Paula Nelson's motor vehicle at the

IN ,THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA
FAMILY DIVISION
SUIT NO. F 2002lC120
BETWEEN KYNAN COOKE PETITIONER
AND SHARON NORA COOKE RESPONDENT
C:
Mrs. Pamela Benka-Coker Q.C. instructed by Mrs. Debra McDonald for the
Respondent/Applicant
Mr. Gordon Steer instructed by Chambers, Bunny & Steer for the Petitioner1
Respondent.
Heard: 2 0&~ 2 2ndM ay, 2003
C;, 1. This is a matter in which the Petitioner/Respondent to the present application

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA
CLAIM NO. C.L.Al13 of 1999
BETWEEN
AND
AND
AND
JUNIOR ANDERSON CLAIMANT
MARITIME TOWING COMPANY iSTD EFENDANT
LIMITED
HYLTON MAXWELL 2ND DEFENDANT
MICHAEL CAMPBELL 3RD DEFENDANT
Mr. Richard Reitzin instructed by Reitzin & Hernandez for the Claimant.
Mr. Jeffrey Daley, instructed by Rattray Patterson Rattray for the Defendants.
Heard gLhS eptember, 6tha nd loLhO ctober, stha nd 9th December 2003
Mangatal J (Ag).

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF JUDICATURE OF JAMAICA (I
IN COMMON LAW
SUIT NO. C.L. 1994lA-083
BETWEEN HARRY ABRIKIAN 1 st PLAINTIFF
AND KOLLEEN RUSSELL 2nd PLAINTIFF
AND ATHOL SMITH 3rd PLAINTIFF
AND ARTHUR W G H T 1" DEFENDANT
AND VERA WRIGHT 2nd DEFENDANT
Messrs. Charles Piper and Emile Leiba instructed by Piper and Samuda for
the 1 " Defendant.
Mrs. J. Samuels-Brown and Miss. Tahlia Maragh for the Plaintiffs.
Heard: 29th May, 26th June and 29th July. 2003
cl Mangatal, J. (AS).